the peloton all access membership vs digital
Guides

Peloton All Access Membership vs Digital (BEST Choice!)

Peloton. It’s a name synonymous with luxury, upscale forms of working out, and it’s undoubtedly one of the biggest crazes in the fitness world.

The company is growing beyond its first and most recognizable product (the Peloton Bike), and now offers two distinct subscription models for Peloton classes: the All-Access vs Digital memberships:

The Peloton All-Access Membership is exclusively for Peloton Bike, Bike+, and Tread owners, while the Digital membership is available to anyone looking to get some sweat in with the Peloton community. They’re two different products that, while they overlap a lot, are designed for two different groups of people.

Keep reading for a more detailed breakdown of the two Peloton subscription options below.

Peloton All Access Membership vs Digital

Peloton, known for cornering the luxury home fitness market and inspiring dozens of competitors, offers two different subscription options:

  • The All-Access Membership, which is required with every Bike, Bike+, or Tread purchase and costs $40/month. 
  • The Digital Membership, which gives members access to a library of workouts and costs $13/month.


Below, I’ll break down the differences between these two membership formats and help you decide which one is right for you!

What is the Peloton All-Access Membership?

Peloton’s All-Access Membership is what’s featured in their commercials: an extensive library of virtual spin/workout classes (more than 7,000), offered both live and on-demand.

Peloton has invested heavily in hiring the best instructors and curating the best environments for their classes, and it’s what has made Peloton the fitness juggernaut that it is. 

That’s not to say that the exercise equipment isn’t worth buying – it’s just that, if all you want is an exercise bike, there are more options than just the Peloton bike.

The All-Access Membership is the company’s biggest selling point, and it’s what sets them apart from the competition

Peloton All-Access Membership

The All-Access membership is also exclusive to Peloton equipment – you can’t have one without the other. Finally, the All-Access membership also gives you access to all of the workouts available in the Peloton Digital membership. So, if you have the All-Access, you also have the Digital membership.

Peloton All-Access costs $39/month.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Tons of Workouts: The Peloton library includes thousands of different rides, treadmill workouts, and “bootcamp” videos (what Peloton calls classes that combine riding with off-bike exercises). You could do a new workout every day for nearly 20 years before you ever repeated one!
  • Live Classes: Don’t want to go into a gym or health club but still want the experience of a live class? Peloton is perfect for you. Every day, there are tons of live classes being run by one of Peloton’s instructors. You get all the excitement and energy of a live workout without having to be around other people – a win-win!
  • Multiple Profiles: Just like with Netflix, Hulu, and HBO Max, you can create a different Peloton profile for every person in your house. The price of the subscription doesn’t change – one, two, even five different profiles, doesn’t matter.

Cons

  • Required for Peloton Equipment: If you buy a Peloton bike, you’re not going to have a choice of whether or not you pay for it, because it’s required to use Peloton equipment. If you cancel your membership, you’re also effectively canceling your ability to enjoy the bike outside of basic “Just Ride” workouts. 
  • Only for Peloton Equipment Owners: If you don’t own a Peloton Bike, Bike+, or Tread, you are unable to purchase or use the Peloton All-Access membership. So, unless you’re planning on making a purchase soon, this membership is not for you!

Who it’s Best For

The Peloton All-Access subscription is the only fitness membership that makes sense for people who own Peloton exercise equipment.

If you think that a Peloton exercise bike or tread could be your ideal way to work out, make sure you like what the membership offers, too – because you can’t have one without the other!

What is Peloton Digital Membership (AKA the Peloton App)?

The Peloton App was created to give people who don’t own Peloton hardware a way to be part of what they call “One Peloton”. It’s part of the company’s bid to transform itself from a seller of luxury spin bikes into a full-scale “lifestyle” fitness company. 

The app gives members access to a wide library of workouts in 10 different categories, from running to yoga and, of course, stationary cycling. You can even watch live workout classes, just like those who own Peloton hardware. 

Peloton Digital Membership

Compared to other fitness app subscriptions, the Peloton app doesn’t seem to be an obvious standout. But, that’s okay – different workout systems are good for different people, and if you want to enjoy some of the Peloton lifestyle, this stellar app is a great way to do just that.

The Peloton Digital App membership costs $12.99/month.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Affordable: This app charges a price that is more than ⅔ less than the price of a Peloton membership, and that’s not even considering the fact that you don’t have to buy a $2,000 bike to get access, either.
  • Multiple Platforms: You can use the digital app on multiple devices, from iOS and Android to AppleTV and Roku.
  • Accessible to All: The Peloton App isn’t just for people who love spinning or using treadmills. You can use it to run outside, do yoga, lift weights – anything you like.

Cons

  • May Lack the Full “Peloton” Experience: Though the company may be trying to branch out beyond the exercise bike image, many people are interested in Peloton for precisely that image. If you want the total Peloton vibe, you’re going to need the bike!
  • Only One Profile Per Account: If there are more than three people in your household who want to work out with Peloton, it would actually be cheaper (speaking in terms of the monthly payment) to go for the full Peloton lifestyle.

Who it’s Best For

This app is the perfect fitness app for anyone who wants to work out with virtual classes in a variety of disciplines.

‘With enough workout classes in different categories to last a lifetime, just about anyone can enjoy the Peloton Digital App.

The Bottom Line: Peloton Bike Membership vs Peloton Digital

The best way to decide between the two types of Peloton memberships is to ask yourself two questions:

  1. Do you want to buy a Peloton Bike, Bike+, or Tread?
  2. Do you want to spend most of your time working out either on or near a bike, or do you like to mix things up?

If you don’t want the exercise equipment, the Peloton Digital membership is the only sensible choice for you. Conversely, if you do want the Peloton hardware, the All-Access membership is literally your only option. 

That’s the real bottom line right there: the Digital membership is the “any budget, any person” option while the Peloton All-Access membership is exclusively for those who own or are planning to own the hardware.

Once you understand the distinctions between the two membership plans, making a choice between them is actually very easy – because there really is only one choice to make, depending on which group of people you fall into!

3 Alternatives to the Peloton Digital App Membership

You may be realizing that, for your situation, neither of the Peloton memberships are right for you. While Peloton is certainly a great choice for most people, you aren’t alone in wondering what else is out there

Here are a few alternatives to Peloton memberships that may be worth considering:

1. Centr ($30/Month)

Created by Chris Hemsworth (yes, Thor himself) and filled with videos from world-class instructors and coaches, Centr is one of the more buzz-worthy workout apps in recent memory. 

The biggest benefit of Centr, compared to other apps, is the heavy focus on mental and diet health alongside exercise. The app has what many would call a “holistic” approach to health, combining meditation and healthy eating with top-notch workouts. 

If you want an app that helps you build several different kinds of wellness, consider Centr!

2. BeachBody on Demand ($99/Year)

They don’t just do infomercials and exercise DVDs anymore – in recent years, BeachBody has made its entire library of famous workouts (remember P90X back in the day? That was BeachBody, too!) available in a monthly subscription format. If you’re interested in any of those programs, give BeachBody on Demand a shot. 

3. Apple Fitness+ ($10/Month)

If a product is trendy, you can bet that Apple is working on its own version of it – whether it’s a self-driving car or a fitness subscription app. 

The good news is, like many Apple products, Apple Fitness+ is damn good. It has an extensive library of workouts, from HIIT to yoga and everything in between. If you love your Apple products, you might just love Apple Fitness+, too.

Conclusion

Peloton’s two membership options can feel a bit confusing to look at, because they only differ in a couple of key ways. Once you understand how Peloton packages and sells its products, you’ll know straight away which subscription you’ll be using. 

Did you get the answers you were looking for? Have any tips or advice for other readers? Leave your thoughts in the comments section below!